LESSON PLAN

check
check
check

Lesson plan

Level B1

The Impact of Generative AI on Artists' Rights

Lesson overview

The rise of generative AI has sparked concern among artists, as their work is replicated without credit or compensation.

Reading text

READING TEXT

In recent years, generative artificial intelligence (AI) has changed the creative arts. It is interesting and a bit worrying to see how this technology has entered the art world. It feels like a big theft. Who thought our creative work could be copied so easily by machines? It is like a magician pulling a rabbit out of a hat, but the rabbit is your artwork, and the magician is a tech company.

In 2022, I saw copies of my work online. At first, these pieces looked like weak imitations. They seemed like they were made by a teenager who just started to make art. My lines and colors were copied by AI image generators that took inspiration from the internet. They used my inspiration without giving me credit or money.

This was not just a personal issue; it felt like an attack on all artists. Imagine billions of images taken from the internet, losing their meaning and value. This feeds a machine that makes art without real feelings. It is a huge theft, and the tech companies do not care about the ethics of it.

In 2023, I spoke at a journalism festival. Many tech advocates said newsrooms must use AI or they will fail. They compared it to horse and buggy makers who could not adapt. They did not mention the threat to writers and artists. I was supposed to talk about my art in war zones, but I ended up discussing the crisis for artists today.

I argued that the tech companies want us to accept this change as normal. But nothing is truly normal; it is about power, money, and politics. If we do not have money, we can still speak out. I worked with journalist Marisa Mazria Katz to write an open letter against AI images in newsrooms. It got thousands of signatures from people around the world who agreed with us.

In January 2023, three illustrators filed a lawsuit against major AI companies. They showed that these companies did not respect the rights of artists. This legal fight is still happening, but it shows that artists are becoming aware and resisting.

It is sad that many people who profit from AI do not care about artists. In 2024, Mira Murati from OpenAI said that some creative jobs should not exist. This shows a lack of empathy among tech leaders. They forget that art is not just a product; it is a human activity with emotions and beauty.

As I think about these changes, I feel sad. The illustration industry is weak, and many artists are losing jobs. The chances for new artists to grow are disappearing. We are being replaced by machines that learn from our work, and the quality of their art is often poor. This change is not just about art; it affects our culture and education.

The idea that this change is progress is dangerous. People who support AI say that those who resist are like the Luddites, who fought against machines. But the Luddites were skilled workers trying to protect their jobs. They lost to force, not progress.

Today, artists are fighting for their jobs and for what it means to create. If we do not unite, we will all lose. The effects of AI go beyond art; they affect our culture and mental health. The tech leaders want profit, but they offer a future without real work and community.

In exchange for human experience, we get a world where robots talk to each other. We must take back our stories, rights, and creative spaces. The fight is not over, and we must keep going for our art and humanity.

Discussion prompts

DISCUSSION PROMPTS

  • 1. What do you think about the role of AI in art?
  • 2. How can artists protect their work in the age of AI?
  • 3. Do you believe AI can create real art? Why or why not?
  • 4. What are some positive and negative effects of technology on creativity?
  • 5. How important is it for artists to unite against AI?
  • 6. What can society do to support artists today?

Key vocabulary

Match each numbered word with the correct lettered definition.

Words

  • 1. generative
  • 2. impact
  • 3. creative
  • 4. artwork
  • 5. community
  • 6. lawsuit
  • 7. empathy
  • 8. technology

Definitions

  • a. a piece of art, such as a painting or sculpture
  • b. the use of scientific knowledge for practical purposes
  • c. a legal case brought to a court of law
  • d. related to making new things or ideas
  • e. a group of people living in the same area or sharing common interests
  • f. the effect or influence of one thing on another
  • g. related to the process of producing or creating something
  • h. the ability to understand and share the feelings of others

MULTIPLE CHOICE

MULTIPLE CHOICE QUESTIONS

Question 1

What has changed in the creative arts recently?

  • a) A) More artists are working together
  • b) B) Generative AI has entered the art world
  • c) C) Art is becoming less popular
  • d) D) Artists are earning more money
Question 2

What did the author and Marisa Mazria Katz do?

  • a) A) They created AI art
  • b) B) They wrote an open letter against AI images
  • c) C) They started a new art school
  • d) D) They held an art exhibition
Question 3

What do tech companies want artists to accept?

  • a) A) That art is not important
  • b) B) That AI is the future
  • c) C) That artists should stop creating
  • d) D) That technology is not useful
Question 4

What does the author compare the current situation of artists to?

  • a) A) A magic show
  • b) B) The Luddites
  • c) C) A new art style
  • d) D) A famous painting

TRUE / FALSE

TRUE / FALSE QUESTIONS

Question 1

The author felt that AI copies are weak imitations.

  • True
  • False
Question 2

The lawsuit was filed by three illustrators.

  • True
  • False
Question 3

The author feels hopeful about the future of art.

  • True
  • False
Question 4

The tech leaders care about the feelings of artists.

  • True
  • False
Question 5

AI art has the same emotional depth as real art.

  • True
  • False

SHORT ANSWER

SHORT ANSWER QUESTIONS

Question 1

What is one effect of AI on artists mentioned in the article?

Question 2

What does the author believe about the fight against AI?

Question 3

What is one reason the author feels sad about the changes in the art world?

Question 4

What do artists need to do to protect their work?

Question 5

What is one effect of AI on culture mentioned in the article?

Question 6

What do tech companies offer in exchange for human experience?

GRAMMAR EXERCISES

GRAMMAR

Grammar Point: Present Perfect Simple vs. Continuous

Why this point appears in the article: The article discusses the ongoing impact of AI on the creative arts, which involves both completed actions and actions that have continued up to the present. What learners need to understand: The present perfect simple is used for actions that have been completed at some indefinite time in the past, while the present perfect continuous emphasizes the duration or ongoing nature of an action that started in the past and continues to the present. Common errors include confusing the two forms, especially when the focus is on the action's completion versus its duration.

Exercises:

Fill in the blank
Complete the sentence with the correct form of the verb in parentheses (present perfect simple or continuous).

  1. I ______ (see) copies of my work online since 2022.

Fill in the blank
Complete the sentence with the correct form of the verb in parentheses (present perfect simple or continuous).
2. The tech companies ______ (not care) about the ethics of using artists' work.

Sentence transformation / rewriting
Rewrite the sentence using the present perfect continuous.
3. I have argued that the tech companies want us to accept this change as normal.
→ I ______ (argue) that the tech companies want us to accept this change as normal.

Error correction
Identify and correct the error in the sentence.
4. Many artists have been losing their jobs since the rise of AI.
→ Many artists ______ (lose) their jobs since the rise of AI.

Short guided paragraph with multiple gaps
Fill in the blanks with the correct form of the verb in parentheses (present perfect simple or continuous).
5. The illustration industry ______ (become) weaker over the past few years. Many artists ______ (struggle) to find work.

Answer key

KEY VOCABULARY

  • 1. generative → g
  • 2. impact → f
  • 3. creative → d
  • 4. artwork → a
  • 5. community → e
  • 6. lawsuit → c
  • 7. empathy → h
  • 8. technology → b

MULTIPLE CHOICE

  • 1. B) Generative AI has entered the art world
  • 2. B) They wrote an open letter against AI images
  • 3. B) That AI is the future
  • 4. B) The Luddites

TRUE / FALSE

  • 1. True
  • 2. True
  • 3. False
  • 4. False
  • 5. False

SHORT ANSWER QUESTIONS

  • 1. Many artists are losing jobs.
  • 2. It is important and must continue.
  • 3. The chances for new artists to grow are disappearing.
  • 4. They need to unite and speak out.
  • 5. It affects our culture and education.
  • 6. A future without real work and community.

GRAMMAR EXERCISES

Answer Key:

  1. have seen — The present perfect simple is used here to indicate that the action of seeing copies has occurred at an unspecified time in the past and is relevant to the present.
  2. have not cared — The present perfect simple indicates that the tech companies have not cared at any time up to now.
  3. have been arguing — The present perfect continuous emphasizes the ongoing nature of the argument.
  4. have lost — The present perfect simple should be used here to indicate the completed action of losing jobs.
  5. has become; have been struggling — The present perfect simple indicates a change that has occurred, while the present perfect continuous emphasizes the ongoing struggle of artists.

Grammar Point: Reported Statements (Tense Backshift)

Why this point appears in the article: The article includes instances where the author discusses past events and opinions, which requires the use of reported speech to convey these ideas accurately. What learners need to understand: When reporting statements, the verb tense often shifts back one tense (e.g., present simple to past simple). Common errors include failing to change the tense or incorrectly maintaining the original tense.

Exercises:

Fill in the blank
Complete the sentence with the correct form of the verb in parentheses (reported speech).

  1. The tech advocates said that newsrooms ______ (must use) AI or they will fail.

Error correction
Identify and correct the error in the sentence.
2. I argued that the tech companies want us to accept this change as normal.
→ I argued that the tech companies ______ (want) us to accept this change as normal.

Sentence transformation / rewriting
Rewrite the sentence in reported speech.
3. "They are losing their meaning and value," the artist said.
→ The artist said that they ______ (lose) their meaning and value.

Matching
Match the direct speech with the correct reported speech.
4. "I will fight for my rights."

a) He said that he fights for his rights.

b) He said that he would fight for his rights.

Fill in the blank
Complete the sentence with the correct form of the verb in parentheses (reported speech).
5. Mira Murati said that some creative jobs ______ (not exist).

Answer Key:

  1. must use — The original modal verb "must" remains unchanged in reported speech.
  2. wanted — The verb "want" needs to shift back to "wanted" to reflect the past tense in reported speech.
  3. were losing — The present continuous "are losing" shifts back to the past continuous "were losing."
  4. b) He said that he would fight for his rights. — The future tense "will" changes to "would" in reported speech.
  5. did not exist — The present simple "do not exist" shifts to the past simple "did not exist."

Grammar Point: Passive Voice

Why this point appears in the article: The article discusses actions taken by tech companies and the impact on artists, which can be expressed in passive voice to emphasize the action rather than the subject. What learners need to understand: The passive voice is used when the focus is on the action or the recipient of the action rather than the doer. Common errors include using the active voice instead of the passive when the subject is not important or unknown.

Exercises:

Fill in the blank
Complete the sentence with the correct form of the verb in passive voice.

  1. My artwork ______ (copy) by AI image generators.

Error correction
Identify and correct the error in the sentence.
2. The rights of artists was not respected by the tech companies.
→ The rights of artists ______ (not respect) by the tech companies.

Sentence transformation / rewriting
Rewrite the sentence in passive voice.
3. The tech companies are making art without real feelings.
→ Art ______ (make) without real feelings by the tech companies.

Fill in the blank
Complete the sentence with the correct form of the verb in passive voice.
4. An open letter ______ (write) against AI images by many artists.

Short guided paragraph with multiple gaps
Fill in the blanks with the correct form of the verb in passive voice.
5. Many images ______ (take) from the internet. This art ______ (create) without real emotions.

Answer Key:

  1. is copied — The passive voice is formed with "is" + past participle "copied" to indicate the action done to the artwork.
  2. were not respected — The passive voice requires the plural "were" to match the plural subject "rights."
  3. is made — The present simple passive form "is made" is used to indicate the ongoing action.
  4. was written — The past simple passive form "was written" indicates that the action was completed in the past.
  5. are taken; is created — The present simple passive form "are taken" indicates a general truth, while "is created" indicates an ongoing action.

Already have an account? Log in

Continue with a free account

Get full access to our downloadable lesson plans for free

Create Free Account